You are here

Opinions

The Middle District of Pennsylvania offers a database of opinions for the years 1999 to present, listed by year and judge. For a more detailed search, enter the keyword or case number in the search box above.

Judge Christopher C. Conner

Plaintiff John Doe alleges 14 claims against several defendants, all arising out of denial of insurance coverage for his gender confirmation surgery. Doe alleges claims against his employer, the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania and its Department of Human Services; the Pennsylvania Employees Benefit Trust Fund and its board and trustees; and several defendants representing his insurance company, Highmark Health Insurance. Doe asserts employment discrimination claims under various federal and state statutes, healthcare discrimination under federal law, and claims for violation of both the United States Constitution and the Pennsylvania Constitution.

Plaintiffs Leonttayy Amir Pratt and Lamont Robinson filed this action seeking equitable and monetary relief for alleged violations of their civil rights committed by the Lebanon County Correctional Facility (“LCCF”) and various LCCF administrators. Specifically, plaintiffs allege that LCCF punished them for refusing to cut off their dreadlocks—an act which would violate plaintiffs’ sincerely held religious beliefs—and discriminated against them on the basis of race.

On December 10, 2020, Governor Tom Wolf and Secretary of Health Rachel Levine issued limited-time mitigation orders in attempt to stem the rising tide of COVID-19 cases and hospitalizations in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. Among other things, those orders prohibit indoor dining at businesses in the retail food services industry through January 4, 2021. (See Doc. 1-2 at 3; Doc. 1-3 at 3).

Chief Judge John E. Jones III

This case arises from the economic havoc wrought by the COVID-19 pandemic. Plaintiffs operated a restaurant that, like far too many businesses across the country, had no choice but to close its doors soon after the virus reached the United States last spring. Plaintiffs submitted a claim to their insurance company, hoping that their business losses would be covered in their all-risk policy.

Defendant United Natural Foods, Inc. (“UNFI”), a Rhode Island corporation, maintains a wholesale food distribution operation in York, PA. On December 16, 2019, UNFI hired Plaintiff Dennis Warner as a loader at that York location.

In the months immediately thereafter, the COVID-19 pandemic hit the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. On March 6, 2020, Governor Wolf declared a state of emergency pursuant to 35 Pa. C.S. § 7301(c). (Id. at ¶ 10). On March 19, Governor Wolf issued an executive order prohibiting all non-life sustaining businesses from operating. (Id. at ¶ 11). For those essential businesses permitted to remain open, compliance with certain mitigation efforts, such as social distancing protocols, was mandated. (Id.). Because Defendant UNFI is a wholesale food distributor, it qualified as an “essential” business and was permitted to remain in operation subject to those mitigation standards. (Id. at ¶ 19).

IN RE Rutter's Inc. Data Security Breach Litigation

Defendant Lavar Jamison objects to his classification as a career offender under the United States Sentencing Guidelines for two reasons. First, Defendant argues that his two predicate offenses should be counted as a single offense because he was sentenced for both convictions on the same day. (Doc. 46).1 Second, Defendant argues that his prior conviction for possession with intent to distribute marijuana does not qualify as a prior controlled-substance offense because the state statue is broader than its federal counterpart. (Doc. 51). For the reasons that follow, we will sustain Defendant’s objection.

Two-and-a-half weeks before a national election of critical importance, Plaintiffs filed the instant suit alleging the improper inclusion of 21,206 supposedly deceased Pennsylvanians on voter rolls. In so doing, it asked us to accept as true its private investigation into the eligibility of thousands of voters. But we cannot and will not take Plaintiff’s word for it—in an election where every vote matters, we will not disenfranchise potentially eligible voters based solely upon the allegations of a private foundation. And, because Plaintiff waited until the eleventh hour to file this suit, there is clearly insufficient time to require Defendant to separately verify Plaintiff’s extensive claims. Thus, for the reasons that follow, we have denied the Motion.

This matter arises in the context of the global COVID-19 crisis. Plaintiff is the owner of a minor league baseball team affiliated with the New York Yankees, whose 2020 season was substantially curtailed due to the ongoing pandemic. Plaintiff alleges it sought relief with a claim pursuant to its business interruption insurance policy.

Judge Matthew W. Brann

Pending before this Court are various motions to dismiss Plaintiffs’ First Amended Complaint. Plaintiffs in this matter are Donald J. Trump for President, Inc. (the “Trump Campaign”), and two voters, John Henry and Lawrence Roberts (the “Individual Plaintiffs”). Defendants, who filed these motions to dismiss, include seven Pennsylvania counties (the “Defendant Counties”), as well as Secretary of the Commonwealth Kathy Boockvar.

Pages